For decades, the Israeli state has exercised control over Palestinian land, movement, and lives. What remains far less examined—but no less disturbing—is the power Israel has asserted over Palestinian bodies after death. Recent viral claims involving Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu have reignited scrutiny of a long-documented history that Israeli officials themselves have acknowledged, yet never fully accounted for.
The latest controversy centers on a resurfaced document allegedly from the 1990s, attributed to then–Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, in which he appears to entertain the legal feasibility of harvesting organs from deceased Palestinians for transplantation into Israelis. While the authenticity and full context of the document circulating online have not been independently verified, Netanyahu’s reported response is notable for what it does not contain: a rejection. Instead, the proposal was referred for legal examination—an act that, at minimum, signals willingness to explore whether such a policy could be sanctioned under Israeli law.
This episode does not exist in a vacuum. It intersects directly with confirmed admissions by Israeli authorities regarding systematic, unauthorized organ removal at Israel’s state forensic institution, the L. Greenberg National Institute of Forensic Medicine, commonly known as the Abu Kabir forensic institute.
Documented Admissions, Not Internet Rumors
In the 1990s and early 2000s, Israeli officials acknowledged that organs—including corneas, skin, heart valves, and bones—were removed during autopsies without the consent of families. The victims were not limited to one group; Palestinians, Israeli citizens, and foreign workers were all affected. However, Palestinians—often killed in circumstances involving state violence and military operations—were uniquely vulnerable, lacking both political power and legal recourse.
Israeli authorities later claimed the practice had ended. No comprehensive criminal accountability followed. No transparent, independent investigation was conducted. Families were not meaningfully compensated. The state effectively closed the file on itself.
To describe this merely as “unauthorized retention” is to sanitize what would be treated elsewhere as a grave violation of medical ethics, human dignity, and international law.
Control Beyond Death
Human rights organizations estimate that Israel continues to withhold the bodies of hundreds of Palestinians, using them as bargaining chips in political negotiations or as tools of collective punishment. Bodies are buried in numbered graves, stored indefinitely, or returned months later under restrictive conditions that deny families proper funerals or independent examinations.
Following Israel’s most recent military operations in Gaza, reports emerged of unidentified human remains returned in sealed bags—raising further questions about what occurred while those bodies were in Israeli custody. Israel has offered no credible, transparent accounting.
Anthropologist and surgical resident Mary Turfah has argued that this system reflects something deeper than isolated abuse. Writing on the political management of Palestinian bodies, she frames these practices as structural—an extension of occupation logic that does not end at death. The Palestinian body, in this framework, remains subject to Israeli state authority even when life has ended.
Within that context, past admissions of organ removal without consent take on new significance. They are not anomalies. They are symptoms.
Netanyahu’s Responsibility
Benjamin Netanyahu has spent decades at the center of Israeli power. He cannot plausibly claim ignorance of institutional practices that were later admitted by the state he led. Nor can he dismiss renewed scrutiny as antisemitic conspiracy when the foundational facts—unauthorized organ removal, body retention, and systematic dehumanization—are established by Israel’s own acknowledgments.
The unanswered question is not whether abuses occurred. They did. The real question is why no accountability followed—and why Israel continues to treat Palestinian bodies as property of the state rather than as human remains entitled to dignity, consent, and justice.
Until Israel opens its archives, permits independent investigations, and ends its policy of body retention, suspicion will persist. Not because of social media rumors, but because secrecy, denial, and impunity create the conditions in which the worst allegations thrive.
This is not about speculation. It is about power without oversight—and the dead who cannot testify.






