Politicians like newly elected Michigan Senator Abdul El-Sayed, congress persons Bernie Sanders and AOC are pushing Medicare for all. Why? Afamily of four can pay $600 a month for health insurance, have a choice of doctors, and still put off an MRI because of a $12,000 family deductible. If the family meets that deductible, it could spend $19,200 in premiums and deductible payments alone in one year. Then the deductible generally resets, even if someone in the family is still being treated for the same illness.
I also witnessed a doctor charge $700 for a consultation that lasted about five minutes. That experience raises a question that gets lost in the debate over who should provide insurance. What should a medical visit cost in the first place, and what protects the patient when the price is excessive or unclear?
Those two examples expose different problems. The first is whether insurance makes care affordable when you need it. The second is how doctors and hospitals set the prices that patients and insurers pay. Medicare for All would change how Americans finance care and give the federal government more leverage over prices. Lawmakers could also tackle excessive charges within the current system. The better approach depends on what we want to fix and how much weight we give to people the current system leaves behind.
What families pay for coverage today
In 2026, the average annual premium for employer-sponsored family coverage reached $28,303, including the employer’s share. According to KFF, workers paid $7,471 on average, about $623 a month and 9% more than the year before. Among covered workers, 13% were in plans that required a worker contribution of at least $12,000 a year for family coverage. At smaller firms, that share was 31%. Those figures are for premiums alone.
In the family-of-four example, $600 a month adds up to $7,200 a year just to keep the insurance. The family reaches $19,200 only if it also has enough expenses that count toward the deductible to meet it. Qualifying preventive care and some other services may be covered before the deductible is met. Depending on the plan, copays or coinsurance can continue until the family reaches its out-of-pocket maximum for covered in-network care. Premiums sit outside that maximum.
A healthy family may spend far less than its deductible. A family managing a chronic illness, repeated procedures, or several children’s medical needs can face thousands in additional bills year after year. Even with a good doctor in the network, the decision to schedule an appointment can come down to whether the family can cover the bill alongside groceries, housing, and child care.
Where the current system works and whom it leaves exposed
The United States combines employer-sponsored insurance, individual plans sold through the Affordable Care Act Marketplace and elsewhere, Medicare, Medicaid, and other public programs. Employer coverage is the most common. When an employer pays most of the premium and offers a plan with a manageable deductible and a good network, that arrangement can work well. Eligible Marketplace customers can also receive subsidies that reduce their costs.
Medicare generally becomes available at 65, including to people who continue working. Some younger people with disabilities qualify as well. Beneficiaries can choose between Original Medicare and private Medicare Advantage. Original Medicare generally has premiums and cost sharing, and it usually excludes routine dental care and most long-term custodial care.
Medicaid provides low-cost coverage to eligible people across age groups. Many enrollees pay no premium, although states can charge certain groups premiums or limited out-of-pocket costs. Some people qualify for both Medicare and Medicaid. Medicaid eligibility varies by state, and access depends partly on which local providers participate. A family can earn too much to qualify and still struggle to afford private coverage.
The current system can also be difficult to navigate. Changing jobs can mean changing plans, paying a new deductible, or finding a new doctor. Self-employed people generally have to arrange their own coverage. Some workers can choose among several insurance plans, while others have limited options through their employers. A plan’s network shapes which doctors and hospitals they can use at in-network prices. Doctors and hospitals have to manage different billing and coverage rules across insurers. And according to the Census Bureau, 8% of Americans went all of 2024 without health insurance.
What Medicare for All would change
The House Medicare for All proposal, H.R. 3069, would establish a federal insurance program with eligibility generally based on U.S. residency. It would cover hospital and physician care, prescription drugs, dental and vision care, and long-term services and supports. Families would pay no premiums, deductibles, or copays for covered care. Coverage would continue through job loss, self-employment, and early retirement.
Patients could choose among participating providers under one program. Existing employer and private plans would give way to the federal program for benefits it covers. Private insurers could still offer coverage for services outside that benefit package. Standard billing rules could reduce administrative work, although moving patients, employers, insurers, and providers to a new system would be a major undertaking.
For a small-business owner or self-employed worker, one practical gain would be knowing that a change in employment or business income would no longer force the family to find a different health plan. For a family facing a $12,000 deductible, the gain would be knowing that a child’s surgery or a parent’s new diagnosis would no longer trigger thousands in deductible payments for covered care. Households with generous employer plans and low out-of-pocket costs would have less room to save and might be more concerned about keeping their current doctors and care arrangements.
Would Medicare for All cost America more or less?
It could go either way. In 2020, the Congressional Budget Office modeled five illustrative single-payer systems. It estimated that total U.S. health spending in 2030 could range from $700 billion less to $300 billion more than projected under the law in place at the time. Lower provider payments and lower insurance administration costs drove the largest savings. Greater use of care drove spending higher, and the breadth of benefits also mattered. Those estimates describe five modeled systems. H.R. 3069 itself was outside the scope of that analysis.
Federal spending would rise because Washington would take over much of the bill now paid through household premiums, employer contributions, out-of-pocket charges, and state programs. A larger federal health budget can coexist with a smaller national health bill when the government takes over those existing costs.
For a household, the comparison is what it would pay under the new financing system against what it pays now in premiums and medical bills. The family in the opening example spends $7,200 on premiums every year, but reaches $19,200 only in a year when it meets the full deductible. Both figures matter when evaluating how that family would fare. Employers’ contributions matter too. If a company stops buying private insurance, workers’ financial gains would depend partly on what the business pays under the new system and whether any savings reach workers through wages or other compensation.
Would Medicare for All lead to rationing?
The most credible concern is that more people could afford care faster than doctors, hospitals, and clinics could expand capacity. If more people can finally see a specialist and appointment slots are already scarce, waits could grow. Scheduled surgeries and other services with existing shortages could face similar pressure. In the single-payer scenarios the Congressional Budget Office examined, people would receive more care overall, yet demand could still outstrip supply and leave more patients waiting for care or unable to get it.
Payment rates matter here. A single federal payer would have more power to bring down prices. If rates or hospital budgets were set too low, some providers could cut staffing, reduce services, or decline to participate. Those effects would be especially serious in rural areas and communities with few alternatives.
A national plan would also set common rules for which treatments, drugs, and procedures it covers. That could make coverage more consistent across the country. A restrictive rule could also affect patients nationwide, so clear criteria and meaningful appeals would matter.
The current system already limits access through costs, narrow networks, prior authorization denials, and local shortages. A family that postpones an MRI because it cannot afford the deductible is already waiting for care. That delay may never show up on a waiting list because the family never books the appointment. Any honest comparison has to count those families alongside the patients who could face longer waits under a new system. Adequate provider payments, staffing, and investment in areas with shortages would help turn broader coverage into timely treatment.
Who is fighting Medicare for All, and why?
Private insurers and major pharmaceutical companies helped organize opposition, along with hospital trade groups. In 2018, industry groups formed the Partnership for America’s Health Care Future, which campaigned against single-payer proposals through lobbying and advertising. The groups involved had different financial interests at stake.
- AHIP and the Blue Cross Blue Shield Association represent health insurers. The House bill would bar private plans from duplicating federal benefits, substantially reducing the industry’s role in providing basic health coverage.
- PhRMA represents major drugmakers. The proposal would give the federal government authority to negotiate prescription drug prices for the program. A purchaser covering most of the country would have substantial bargaining power.
- The American Hospital Association and the Federation of American Hospitals represent hospitals. A national program would change how hospitals are paid. Those that now command high commercial rates could lose revenue, depending on the payment rates and operating budgets adopted.
The American Medical Association helped found the coalition and withdrew in 2019. At the time, it said it still opposed Medicare for All and favored expanding coverage through a mix of public and private insurance. The U.S. Chamber of Commerce has also opposed single-payer proposals. Lobbying disclosures have listed H.R. 3069 among the bills on which AHIP, the AMA, and others lobbied. Those filings identify the subject of the lobbying. By themselves, they leave open what position a group took in a particular meeting or how much it spent on that bill.
Industry financial interests are a real part of the debate. People who already have good coverage may also reasonably ask what they would pay in taxes, whether their doctors would participate, how long they would wait for surgery, and whether their local hospital could keep its services open. Some support broader coverage and prefer expanding Medicaid, offering a public insurance option, or capping hospital prices while retaining private plans.
Political messaging can make those choices harder to evaluate. A warning about higher taxes can leave out the premiums and medical bills that could disappear. A warning about longer waits can leave out patients who already postpone care because of cost. Supporters of Medicare for All owe the public an equally clear account of what families would pay and how hospitals and clinics would handle more patients seeking care.
What a $700 consultation tells us about medical prices
When a doctor charges $700 for a short consultation, patients should be able to see what the provider charged, what the insurer allowed, and what the patient owes. If $700 was the initial charge, the insurer may have negotiated a lower rate. If $700 was the allowed amount and the visit applied to an unmet deductible, the patient could owe the full allowed amount. An itemized bill and the insurer’s explanation of benefits can help show how the visit was billed and whether there was a separate facility charge.
A patient should be able to get that information before a scheduled visit whenever possible. But knowing the price and having the power to change it are two different things. A patient with a limited network or only one local specialist may have little ability to shop around. High hospital and physician prices also feed into premiums, so the issue affects people who rarely visit a doctor.
Four reforms that could reduce bills under the current system
| Reform | How it would work | What lawmakers would need to protect |
|---|
| Cap high prices and limit annual increases | Set a maximum total payment for selected hospital and physician services, potentially using a multiple of Medicare’s rate. Prevent providers from billing patients for amounts above the cap. CBO found that price caps could reduce commercial prices more than transparency or competition measures alone in the first decade. | Set rates that keep essential services available, particularly at rural and safety-net hospitals. |
| Limit facility fees for routine office care | Pay comparable amounts for services that can safely be delivered in a physician’s office or a hospital-owned outpatient clinic. | Preserve appropriate payment for care that requires hospital staff, equipment, or emergency readiness. |
| Require meaningful estimates before scheduled care | Show the clinician’s charge, any facility fee, the insurer’s negotiated rate, and the expected patient share before the appointment. | Recognize that estimates help most when care can be scheduled and patients have alternatives. CBO expects transparency alone to have a relatively small effect on overall prices. |
| Scrutinize hospital mergers and track where savings go | Review mergers that leave patients and insurers with few local alternatives. Where regulators review premiums, require insurers to show how changes in provider prices affect proposed rates. | Track whether lower claims costs reach families and employers. Competition reforms can take years to affect prices. |
Bottom line — Experts would choose Medicare for All
Experts would choose Medicare for All because it offers stronger protection when people get sick and keeps coverage in place when their lives change. The current system can serve people well when their employers subsidize good plans. Its biggest weakness is that affordable care can disappear with a job change or become out of reach because of a deductible. I give more weight to whether families can afford treatment when they need it, including those who never make it onto a waiting list.
That judgment comes with concrete requirements. Congress would need to show households and businesses what they would pay. Provider rates and hospital budgets would need to sustain care, especially in places with few alternatives. The transition would need enough staffing and capacity to handle additional demand, along with clear coverage rules and meaningful appeals. Whether the country spends less overall depends on those design choices.
We can also pursue price reform now. Targeted payment caps and limits on routine facility fees are the most direct ways to address charges like the $700 consultation, and Congress can enact them while private insurance remains in place. Medicare for All is the better long-term choice in my view because it tackles the problem price caps alone leave unresolved. A family’s ability to get covered care would no longer depend on keeping a particular job or finding thousands of dollars when the deductible resets.