BUFFALO, N.Y. — A Burmese refugee who was nearly blind and allegedly abandoned miles from his home by Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents during freezing winter conditions has been found dead, prompting national outrage and renewed scrutiny of federal immigration enforcement practices.
Police confirmed Wednesday that Nurul Amin Shah Alam, a Rohingya refugee who fled persecution in Myanmar, died after failing to find his way home following an encounter with ICE last week. According to officials and advocates, Shah Alam was dropped off outside a Tim Hortons in Buffalo, New York — approximately five miles from his residence — without assistance, notification to family members, or apparent concern for his severe visual impairment.
Temperatures in the area at the time were near freezing.
Shah Alam’s body was discovered days later after he never returned home.
Public Officials Demand Answers
Buffalo Mayor Sean Ryan condemned the incident in a statement, calling the death “deeply disturbing” and accusing Immigration and Customs Enforcement of a “dereliction of duty.”
“The preventable death of Nurul Amin Shah Alam is deeply disturbing,” Ryan said. “Immigration and Customs Enforcement must answer for how and why this happened.”
ICE has not yet released a detailed public explanation of the circumstances surrounding Shah Alam’s release.
Experts and Advocates Express Fury
The incident has ignited fury among immigration advocates, legal analysts, and elected officials, many of whom argue that Shah Alam’s death was foreseeable and avoidable.
Aaron Reichlin-Melnick, a senior fellow at the American Immigration Council, wrote that abandoning a vulnerable individual under such conditions was “a recipe for disaster.”
“To take someone so vulnerable and drop them off so far from their home in the middle of winter without notifying family?” Reichlin-Melnick wrote. “It is truly enraging.”
Legal analyst Chris Geidner echoed that sentiment, writing that the facts alone were damning.
“To read the words is to damn all involved,” Geidner said.
Calls for Criminal Accountability
Some critics have gone further, openly questioning whether criminal charges should be considered.
New York State Assembly candidate Adam Bojak argued that the conduct would likely have resulted in prosecution had it been committed by a private citizen.
“If any private citizen had done this, they would almost certainly be charged with a crime,” Bojak wrote. “Make no mistake about it: ICE killed Nurul Amin Shah Alam.”
Legal experts note that while federal agents are often shielded by qualified immunity, the circumstances of Shah Alam’s death could invite civil litigation or congressional investigation.
A Refugee Who Escaped Persecution — Only to Die Alone
Shah Alam was a member of the Rohingya ethnic minority, a group that has faced widespread violence, displacement, and persecution in Myanmar. Advocates say he had sought safety in the United States, only to die alone after being left disoriented in a city he could not navigate.
As of Wednesday night, ICE had not announced any internal investigation, disciplinary action, or changes to policy.
For many observers, the silence has only intensified the anger.
“This didn’t have to happen,” one advocate wrote online. “And that’s what makes it unforgivable.”


















